Its embarrassing to say that I have been here a month trying to, admittedly among other things, attract a large capital investment into this project and it was only last week that it dawned on me that it might make sense to write a formal project proposal. I downloaded a few documents on how to write an attractive proposal for the dispersal of funds to NGOs and have been working through what is required to be able to ask for a million dollars without sounding like an idiot. There are a variety of banking and governmental organisations which exist for the sole purpose of loaning money to microfinance banks (sometimes known as microfinance wholesalers) and all they need is a statement of intent and a couple of good people to run it, and of course promise to pay it back.
Despite the variety of different sources of funding for microfinance banks, the 'retail' side of it is still underfunded and there is a far bigger potential market than is being currently provided for. Ways to be able to provide low-cost, unfixed loans to banks are sorely needed and as large funders are often wary of risking large amounts of money, the public are increasingly being looked to through websites like Kiva (www.kiva.org) to attract people to fund small projects. A way in which legal and psychological constraints can be overcome so as to provide for the funding of such projects needs t be worked out so that microfinance can truly be turned into an economic base which is funded by the people, for the people.
It is the legal constraints which all too often hold up progress here too. The Mozambican currency, the 'metical', cannot legally be transferred out of the country and it is impossible to exchange outside the country. People are legally required to be paid in 'meticais' (plural) inside the country so that all wealth gained through working in Mozambique eventually returns to Mozambique. Very clever. Except when trying to attract investment from outside the country to be invested in bank accounts here and then be repaid (with interest) at the end of the agreed loan period. There is a way of declaring all incoming investment as a loan which will allow it to be repaid at a later date but no interest can be added to that on its way out. Accounts in foreign currencies can be kept in the country but do not carry the same very generous interest rate on savings (around 19%) that accounts in meticais do. Therefore, without relying on the dangerous task of consistently attracting enough future investment into a European account to repay the previous loan and therefore be able to keep a small quantity of constantly rolling capital in a high-interest account in Mozambique while turning over capital in a European account, a way has to be found of rewarding investors, big and small, for their faith in the ability of microfinance to repay their loan from a Mozambican account. That requires legislative change.
Legislative change is hard to bring about when it derives from a small rural charity which does not yet provide any banking facilities and is run by two recent university graduates with no discernible experience in banking, business or international development. So for now, transfers are difficult.
Furthermore, we are currently a registered charity. Charities cannot by law take money from the people they are trying to help, for very good reason. This means that we cannot begin to mobilise what is arguably a more important service than bank loans, the ability to save. Savings facilities were brought in well after loans in the history of microfinance but it is now generally accepted that one cannot adequately exist without the provision of the other. The lack of ability to save means that all the money brought in from the new businesses which are created is either constantly unsafe (the 'under-the-mattress' savings method) or is spent as quickly as possible on consumables, thereby totally contradicting one of the primary reasons for the provision of microfinance, that of income smoothing and the ability to cope with income shocks. Without the ability to easily transfer money in and out of the bank on a fully commercial basis, provide savings as well as loans provision and generally make it easier for the market to expand to those at the bottom, all of the evidence points towards the lack of long-term efficiency of banking provision. The reason for these difficulties? Government legislation. Which brings about the interesting question: Is the left-wing assertion that larger government involvement benefits those at the bottom universally true? Because in this case it is precisely that interference which is preventing capitalism from including those at the bottom of the pile in Mozambique.
Anyway, onto happier matters. Friday was my 23rd birthday so we went for a weekend holiday to one of the most interesting places I've ever been- Ilha de Moçambique, Mozambique Island. Vasco de Gama, the famous Portuguese explorer and namesake of at least a couple of football teams, landed on Ilha in the 16th century and started building churches. The Portuguese are good at building churches. When they started controlling the trade routes from India, around the Cape and up to Europe there were a variety of people who wanted to take relieve the Portuguese of their control over Ilha. At this point these churches turned into fortresses. The Portuguese managed to hold onto this tiny island (a couple of miles long, only a few hundred metres wide) and maintain it as the capital of Mozambique, then Portuguese East Africa, until the 19th Century when, for economic reasons, the capital was changed to Maputo, then called Lorenço Marques. Anyway, brought up to the present day it is a bizarre mix of Arabic, Portuguese and African architecture packing 10,000 people into an island a fraction of the size of Unst.
We got the boat there early on Friday morning, the journey taking about 2 and a half hours and costing 50p. Upon arriving at the shore we learned first-hand why Ilha is not the ideal holiday location. Most tropical islands are considered beach resorts with swimming the main appeal. Ilha lacks that appeal for two reasons. The first is that much of the island is built up and what shoreline there is is stony and awkward to swim on. The second is that the overcrowding of the island means that it lacks proper sanitary facilities. People poo on the beach. For this reason the waters around Ilha are some of the most polluted in the world and extra special care must be taken when jumping out of a small sailing boat into the shallow waters to dodge such things.
Anyway, we went to check in at a small hotel called O Escondidinho. The hotel has about 20 rooms, is towards the upper range but still only costs £25-40 per night. The main appeal is the pool. Due to the aforementioned issues with swimming, pools are a major selling point in hotels on the island. This one though was extra special. The pool was dug into a platform next to the hotel bar, surrounded on two sides with the balconies where the rooms were situated. As well as being a major trade route for spices and arms being traded between India and Europe, Ilha was for a long time the world's busiest slave-trading port. Before the platform was dug out to create the lovely quaint pool, it was used to show off slaves to be bought by guests assembled on the balconies above. A memorial garden set inside the ruins of an old slave 'warehouse' five minutes down the road was dedicated to the memory of those who were trafficked through Ilha. The locals there however aren't unduly bothered by it, their ancestors being the collaborators with, not the victims of, the trade. The mainly white clientèle didn't seemed too fussed about this either, especially after the hot chocolate cake and ice-cream which the hotel is famous for.
We got lunch at a relatively new restaurant called 'The Golden Anchor', owned by a Swedish woman. The food was good and reasonably priced and it was a good start to the day. Its wide-open French window style doors meant that everyone walking past could see and smell the food and small groups of young boys would stand and pull faces at people sitting inside before being shouted at by the waiters and bolting down the street. One such young boy was selling a piece of history. He had three old coins, each bearing the face of a 19th century King of Portugal with the years 1883 and 1884 on them. They looked genuine. The boy was selling the seemingly priceless artefacts for £2 each. Bargain. We had recently been informed that the Ilha Museum which was being done up with money donated by UNESCO (which had recently made Ilha a World Heritage Site) had been broken into after UNESCO hadn't included any security provision in its budget. We decided not to encourage the theft of priceless historical currencies by not purchasing them. They were cool though.
After lunch we went to the fortress, the barracks which proudly proclaimed to have fended off attacks from however many great civilisations and not fallen. It had much of your usual stuff- lots of cannons, high turreted walls, everything from bars to toilets to parade grounds inside, with a couple of churches thrown in for good measure too (including allegedly the oldest building in the southern hemisphere). But the most impressive thing was the water. Each of the rooftops was shaped in such a way as to provide an elaborate water diverting system. We hadn't really considered this before but a castle surrounded by salt-water which regularly came under siege may well need a lot of supplies of water. All of these channels lead down into three massive tanks of water, still existent after 500 years, providing absolutely clean, clear rainwater to whoever was stationed there. Say what you want about the Portuguese but they knew a thing or two about water.
The entire castle was built with slave labour and took over 60 years to complete (our guide and friendly army-man Essiar told us, before asking for 'a coke' at the end of the tour...). If slaves refused to build they were taken outside the castle walls, tied to a concrete pillar and killed by firing squad, before being lobbed over the rocks into the sea. People tended to keep building. After the threat of overthrow had reduced a bit a bridge was built to the mainland. A single-track, rickety old bridge stretches over two miles to connect this bizarre place with portuguese architecture lining every street and grand looking mansions crumbling into the sea, to the mainland, mud-huts as far as the eye can see and no discernible tourism for miles.
Ilha provides another prime example of the huge demand for banking facilities in the region. There is a beautiful old bank in Ilha, still with all the old architecture inside and with the luxury of an ATM in the porch. A common sight outside the doors, as it is in next to every ATM in Nampula City and indeed the whole region is queues. People queue for over an hour, sometimes nearer two or three, to withdraw money. If there is not queue outside an ATM it is more often than not because it has run out of money, as had happened this weekend. People here are so desperate for facilities to save and borrow that they will spend most of an afternoon waiting to withdraw from a system which was meant to make the whole operation much faster. I'm not looking to incorporate ATMs into a microfinance bank but a similarly quick and easy way to take out money is definitely needed.
The weekend ended on a bit of a downer as Celisse got food-poisoning from a dodgy prawn curry and so Saturday night was pretty relaxed. We just caught the boat on Sunday as it was setting off five minutes early, nearly completely empty. Public transport across Africa tends to leave when its full and so this early exit was very rare. We soon discovered the reason for the hurry. Our tiny little wooden boat was being tossed about by a strong wind and tide that regularly splashed waves over the side and more than a couple of times had everyone on board (an old man, a jolly middle-aged woman, the skipper and his grandson and us two) collectively clenching. The journey to Ilha can sometimes take up to 3 and a half hours depending on the wind. We made it back in less than one, feeling a little worse for wear when we got back on dry land.
All in all a mixed but for the most part excellent way to spend my 23rd birthday. Back to the upcoming week, I'm gonna really make a good go at this project proposal, hopefully work on it for the next couple of weeks and fire it off to someone with money. Celisse is constantly gaining more students to teach english to and the one remaining dog is clinging to life. I hope we'll all be doing exactly the same in a weeks time.